Who is afraid of the Chinese state? Evidence calling into question political fear as an explanation for overreporting of political trust

Published by Political Psychology

5 February 2018

Daniela Stockmann
Hertie School of Governance, Berlin

Ashley Esarey
University of Alberta, Edmonton

Jie Zhang
Communication University of China, Beijing

 

ABSTRACT:


Public opinion polls show that political trust tends to be higher in authoritarian regimes compared to liberal democracies. Many scholars have argued that respondents may provide false answers out of fear about repercussions by the state, thereby skewing survey results in a positive direction. Using an unobtrusive measure based on affect transfer, we find that adult participants in experiments conducted in China transfer positive affect toward the state onto evaluations of television advertisements upon mere exposure to the name of a central party institution. Participants did not have incentives to lie because they did not associate the advertisements with the state. Furthermore, people who evaluated the ads more positively upon viewing the name of the state also reported more positive levels of trust in government. Together, these findings raise doubt that Chinese misrepresent political trust in surveys out of political fear.

 

Read the full article