Head of Research Anton Malkin on China's Industrial Policy Model at Columbia University
12 November 2026
TCI’s Head of Research, Dr. Anton Malkin, joined scholars around the world to discuss the resurgence of industrial policy. He presented research on China’s experience, exploring the state’s role and limitations in shaping domestic green industries, and participated in comparative discussions of shared and distinct challenges and policy responses in the EU and the US.
Highlights
- How China’s model works: Anton’s discussions centred on how China has combined long-term state planning with fierce market competition. The centre sets the direction and the time horizon, while cities, provinces and firms compete within it.
- Beyond the trade debate: Much analysis of China’s approach focuses on its effects on trading partners, including subsidies, overcapacity and state-backed champions. Anton noted that these debates can crowd out a more basic question: how the system actually works, and what lessons it might offer economies built very differently.
- What can travel: Many elements of China’s approach, such as long planning horizons and competition among regions, do not depend on its political system. Anton observed that the hardest element for democracies to rebuild is consistency over time.
- China and the EU compared: Both steer long-term industrial change through heavy state involvement, through planning in China and regulation in the EU. Yet they sit at opposite ends on how well the state knows what the firms it supports are doing; in Europe, much of that information sits with member states or with the firms themselves.
- A connected conversation: The workshop convenors, Nils Kupzok (Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies), Matthias Thiemann (Sciences Po) and Josh Whitford (Columbia University), also moderated sessions at Friday’s conference, which closed with Heather Boushey, Elisabeth Reynolds and Joseph Stiglitz on industrial policy amid global turbulence.
China’s rise in electric vehicles, batteries and other clean technologies is challenging established industries in developed economies and prompting debates over the effectiveness of its industrial policy. For Canada, understanding the drivers of China’s success and the trade-offs in its industrial policy could help inform decisions on investment in its own automotive and battery sectors d. The special issue is in development, and TCI will share updates as the work progresses.
