User Experience Research: Stone-Olafson Report Summary
28 October 2026
Overview & Methodology
In 2025, user research was conducted with the agency Stone-Olafson to better understand the experiences of the U of A community using the university’s website. This research included faculty, staff and students and was conducted via a mix of quantitative and qualitative to better understand users’ needs and experiences. Key findings and recommendations are outlined below.
The user research provided valuable data regarding users’ overall sentiment of the university website and gathered specific anecdotal feedback about what could be improved. 701 survey responses (from 264 students and 437 staff) informed the quantitative findings of the study, while 50 one-on-one interviews yielded rich qualitative data about users’ experiences.
Key findings
Quantitative research
Sentiment
Quantitative surveys revealed an even split regarding overall website satisfaction, with 37% of users reporting positive sentiment, 37% neutral and 26% negative. Students reported more positive sentiment (46%) than faculty and staff (28%). The overall results were higher than expected given anecdotal feedback received about the website. Even so, the quantitative research revealed that users are divided on their experience with the website and clear areas for improvement exist. Moreover, these experiences shape impressions of the university itself with 48% of faculty and staff saying it negatively affected their feelings about U of A.
Search
The ease of finding information was a major contributor to how people feel about the website. The survey found that 57% of respondents stated that they find the information they’re looking for on the U of A website all of the time or most of the time. When using the site, most users start with either Google search or the internal site search. Undergraduate program information was easiest to find (63% rated it easy), while transportation and financial information were hardest (33–34%). Users reported that general information and commonly searched pages can be found easily but the more specific information can be difficult to find. Staff tend to rely on the internal search tool which typically underperforms Google search.
Navigation
The survey also examined which content staff and students most needed from the website and which pages were most difficult to find. Staff identified their biggest needs as technology and tools, personal records, finance and health information. Students ranked tuition and financial support and academic support as their most needed information. Finance is the one topic identified as a gap by both audiences: it is a top-three priority for each, yet among the hardest topics to find. User responses indicated a desire for the navigation menu to be organized around the tasks they need to complete. The top-ranked needs for both audiences are closely tied to daily work and study.
Staff Usage
Critically, 60% of staff reported daily usage of the university website, while only 6% of students engage in daily usage — using eClass, Canvas and BearTracks more regularly. This reaffirmed that heavier users of the site (faculty and staff) encounter issues more frequently as they require specific information related to their work. Although the web experience needs to be improved for all audiences, specific solutions needed to be considered for staff.
Contact Information
Finding the right contact is a top need across audiences. Contacting the university and facilities information were the two most important categories for both staff and students, This echoed qualitative research via interviews, in which virtually all participants wanted more contact information throughout the site.
Qualitative research
One-on-one interviews provided in-depth feedback on users’ experiences with the U of A website. This qualitative data was critical to identify pain points and areas of improvement for the site. The following key findings were distilled from interviews with the university community:
Inaccurate Information
Inaccurate and out-of-date information across different sites makes it difficult for users to trust what they find. Faculty pages that repeat institutional content are the most likely to be outdated, and internal search often surfaces them ahead of the institutional source.
Inconsistent Navigation
Users have difficulty learning how to navigate the U of A site due to inconsistency in navigation and page design. Participants could not apply the navigation approach learned in one area of the site to another.
Duplication
Users reported difficulty finding relevant information due to duplicated content, which creates a high volume of content and makes search results less useful. In testing, users stopped scanning at the first heading that looked like a match, often missing the most relevant result further down the list.
Search
Users typically start from Google search — and increasingly generative AI — or start browsing from the ualberta.ca homepage. Interview participants more often began tasks with a keyword search than by browsing, and none began browsing from a faculty landing page.
Navigation
Users browse through the top navigation to try to learn U of A structure and processes.
Page Titles
Users respond to labels that describe what they need, not how the university is organized. Updating page titles that appear in search results accordingly would make search more useful.
Text Density
Users prefer pages that are easier to scan, requiring simpler page content. Text-dense pages were described as overwhelming and intimidating.
Summaries and Process Explanation
Users desire more summaries and process diagrams on pages to help guide them through complex processes.
Content Governance
Users expressed a desire for some monitoring and accountability to ensure content stays up to date and consistent. Interviewees asked for clear content ownership, update cycles and audits while content editors described the current update process as a barrier to keeping information current.
Key Recommendations
Key recommendations were synthesized based on user experiences reported via the survey and interviews, focusing on improvements to the U of A’s digital presence:
- Consistency: Navigation and page design should be consistent across U of A web pages to help users navigate and find content they need quickly and effectively.
- Accuracy: Inaccurate and out-of-date information should be removed, which will help users find current, reliable information and improve search results.
- Reduce duplication: Removing duplicate content will reduce volume and complexity of digital content, improving search results and reducing likelihood of inaccurate information.
- Discoverability: Content should be organized to support users preferred engagement methods — typically starting from Google search and increasingly generative AI or browsing from the ualberta.ca homepage.
- Accountability: Pages should have clear owners and a monitoring mechanism to ensure content stays up-to-date and consistent.
Implementing recommendations
The key findings and recommendations from this research illustrate a generally positive user experience with the university website but reaffirmed that the web experience needs to be improved for faculty and staff. While updating the university’s 100,000+ web pages is a large undertaking, the key recommendations outlined above translate this feedback into clear and actionable opportunities for improvement.
To achieve short-term improvements, style changes were implemented in Summer 2026 across the university web site to improve scanability, accessibility and common page design elements.
The Digital Content and Web Transformation (DCWT) program has embedded these key recommendations as guiding principles to the establishment of the new faculty and staff intranet, redesign of ualberta.ca, and establishment of digital governance standards across the university — anticipated to be completed in 2028.
For questions related to DCWT, please contact the program team at dcwt@ualberta.ca.